Yesterday I watched a news broadcast I found deeply disturbing. I have been trying to gather my thoughts since then as I have been thinking about this for some time. I am going to do my best to present this as logically as possible and we will see if it leads to some interesting discussion.

It is no secret that the media holds the power to change public opinion. It is also no secret that it does just that. I believe that the biggest culprits are news media and Hollywood movies. Both of which I will discuss here.

Let’s start with the ABC news story that ran last evening about the opening of an arabic school in NYC. Go ahead, read the whole thing. This should not be an issue since there are other similar schools for other languages and they don’t cause controversy. For those that didn’t read, this school will not be taught all in Arabic, but that classes in the language and culture are mandatory. It follows US school system curriculum so what exactly is the issue? The fact is that we are now living in a global society. I think for our children it will be difficult to compete without knowledge of additional languages. Not to mention, it is extremely wise for US children to learn that there are other languages and cultures besides our own. Our nation is vast and we have a tendency to forget that there is a world outside of our borders that may not always think as we do. Not to mention that our view of that world is so skewed because all we know is what the media tells us rather than what we have experienced.

Now, let me tell you a bit about the story that ran on TV, the part that I found disturbing. You will see in the article this quote: “I think there’s a special problem with an Arab school because of the reality of the world that we live in today,” said Brooklyn Assemblyman Dov Hikind. “The sad reality is that a lot of the terrorism, not a lot, almost all of it, has come from a particular community — a minority — but a particular community. That’s a reality we better face.”

What you don’t see is that this is coming from an orthodox Jew. Now, I have nothing against any of these religions or cultures, but don’t insult my intelligence by having the only person in the report not condoning the school by a man like this. Do you notice that this guy has it out for Muslims? Do you see that he encourages racial profiling? He doesn’t recognize Martin Luther King day? But I am sure he would be the first one to throw a fit if we start racial profiling against Jews! If you want to report that some find this school controversial, do so, but don’t do so in a way that immediately raises my dander. I find this particularly dangerous reporting because most people aren’t going to even notice who they have used to report something and just take it as fact. *sigh*

Now let me talk a bit about Hollywood. Recently I have noticed that almost every movie I see has some derogatory reference to Muslims even when it isn’t the least bit warranted nor necessary to a story line. I remember this being the case with Christianity in my childhood. The most blaring example I came across though was with September Dawn. (The first September 11) Basically it takes place in Utah in 1857, an incident where a wagon train stopping for rest on their way to California is massacred by Mormons who had settled there after being driven out of Missouri. I had never heard of this story until this movie came out. (I know I have a few Mormon readers and feel free to correct me on this one, or present another side of the story since I am ALL for discussion on this post!!!)

In the movie, there is a section where the the local Mormon leader is remembering being persecuted by people in Missouri and there is whole sections of this that talk about Islam, Muhammad, the Qur’an, etc. Now I ask you, were there really that many middle eastern people in the mid-west in 1857? Maybe I am wrong but I think not. I don’t think it is a logical correlation at all. Feel free to correct me if I am wrong. It really just struck me as taking a shot at a religion that had nothing to do with the storyline once again.

My mother suggested that perhaps Hollywood was taking a potshot at any fundamental religion it could get its hands on. I suspect she is right.

Also, do you suppose this movie has come out because we have a possible presidential candidate who is Mormon?

Think people!

Open for discussion, much discussion appreciated. I’d like to see what others’ views on this subject are!

3 thoughts on “Media

  1. Hey Kara! I haven’t done any research on the predominance of Muslim immigrants in the 150’s, but I do find it interesting that Jefferson felt it necessary to read and own a copy of the Koran (translated, I think) because he was concerned about a Muslim threat to the nation.
    I just dug around for an article I read a while back – here is an excerpt:

    “I looked for an answer to that question this past week. What I found was absolutely fascinating: Jefferson needed that copy of the Koran because he was desperate to learn something about Islam from that religion’s written de facto standard of all things Muslim. Why? Because the United States was going to war in the early 1800s against conservative, Wahhabi-type, radical Muslims.

    (As only the third president of the United States, Jefferson had no CIA to feed intelligence data to him and to his national security advisor. Come to think of it, Jefferson had no national security officer.)

    During the early formative years of the United States, our forefathers fought an international group of terrorists who, like today’s conservative, Wahhabi-type, radical Muslims, made no distinction between geopolitical nation states. They were called the Barbary Pirates. They were from the Barbary Coast of North Africa. Allusion to the affair can be found in the words “…to the shores of Tripoli” mentioned in the Marine Corps Hymn.”

    The article has much more detail in it – apparently the majority of Muslims herein described were Pirates threatening trade and demanding tribute.
    Hope it helps!

  2. Hi Sonya!

    Thank you so much for that information, I apparently didn’t do much additional research. Very interesting. If nothing else, it makes the premise of the insertion into the movie somewhat more plausible.

  3. I’m not sure Brigham Young would have said anything about the Muslims. I know he was a well educated man and very well read, I seem to recall him knowing a lot about history and other religions. However the group he was talking to would not have known, nor cared about any other religion. All they cared about at the time was not being persecuted like they were in Missouri and Illinois….

    I shall have to look at this further. I’ve not been to see the movie but have heard that from our point of view, it’s not very accurate. (The point of view of being a Mormon. :-d)

    Point being I kind of think your Mom was right. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.